Home / Best Software by Task

Best Software for Small Business Payroll: Totals at 3, 10, and 25 Workers

Colleagues working together in an office, counting money and discussing projects.

Photo: Pavel Danilyuk / Pexels

The short answer: one table, three team sizes

Payroll is the category where sticker prices lie most politely: a low per-worker rate can ride on a high base fee, and the cheapest plan can exclude the tax filing that is the entire point. Here is the whole decision in one table, at prices checked on vendor pages in November 2026.

Provider and plan3 workers10 workers25 workersWho files your payroll taxes
Gusto Simple ($49 base + $6/worker)$67/mo$109/mo$199/moGusto files
OnPay ($49 base + $6/worker)$67/mo$109/mo$199/moOnPay files
Patriot Basic ($17 base + $4/worker)$29/mo$57/mo$117/moYou file
Patriot Full Service ($37 base + $5/worker)$52/mo$87/mo$162/moPatriot files
Interactive tool

Software Finder

Answer three questions and get a shortlist from our checked data set, not a logo wall.

What job are you hiring software to do?

Patriot Payroll

Budget payroll with a do-it-yourself tax tier and a full-service tier, priced per worker.

From $4 per user/mo billed annually

Figures from the vendor comparison chart on patriotsoftware.com, checked November 19, 2026.

No free plan; free trial offered

Best for: budget-first single-state employers, owners comfortable filing taxes on the Basic tier, very small crews

Official site and pricing

Gusto

Full-service payroll and basic HR priced as a monthly base fee plus a per-person fee.

From $6 per user/mo billed annually

Gusto prices are a base fee plus a per-person fee; the plan figures here are the per-person rates. Cross-checked against multiple independent dated reads of gusto.com/product/pricing in October and November 2026.

No free plan; month-to-month pricing with no long-term contract

Best for: small teams hiring W-2 employees, owners who want payroll taxes handled, businesses adding benefits

Official site and pricing

OnPay

Single-plan payroll with one published price and multi-state filing included.

From $6 per user/mo billed annually

Base and per-worker figures cross-checked against multiple independent dated reads of the vendor pricing in October and November 2026.

No free plan; one plan, no tiers

Best for: multi-state small employers, businesses that hate tier ladders, niche industries with mixed W-2 and 1099 staff

Official site and pricing

Square Payroll

Payroll from the payments company, priced for hourly teams already running Square.

From $6 per user/mo billed annually

Prices cross-checked against multiple independent dated November 2026 reads of squareup.com payroll pricing; checked November 20, 2026.

No free plan

Best for: restaurants and retail on Square, hourly teams with tips, very small employers

Official site and pricing

Prices and plan facts checked against vendor pricing pages on November 18, 2026. Vendors change prices; the official site link is the final word.

The tax-filing split: the first decision

Every payroll purchase is secretly two purchases: calculation and filing. Calculation is arithmetic: gross to net, withholdings, deductions. Filing is the legal act: depositing withheld taxes on schedule, submitting quarterly and annual forms (941s, 940, state returns, W-2s), and answering when an agency disagrees. Patriot's two tiers make the split visible and price it honestly: Basic at $17 base plus $4 per worker is calculation only, you file; Full Service at $37 base plus $5 per worker is calculation plus filing. At 10 workers the difference is $30 a month, $360 a year, for never personally owing the IRS a correctly-timed deposit.

Our position: for most small businesses, full service is the correct default, and Basic is a specialist product for owners with a bookkeeper or accountant who already files. Payroll tax penalties are unforgiving and boring in equal measure; a missed deposit is not a learning experience anyone needs twice. The table's cheapest row is only cheapest if your filing labor and penalty risk are worth less than $30 a month.

Gusto and OnPay: the tied headline, the real differences

Gusto Simple ($49 base plus $6 per worker, single-state payroll) and OnPay ($49 base plus $6 per worker, one plan) tie exactly on headline price at every size in our table: $67, $109, $199. The tie breaks on structure. Gusto is a ladder: Plus ($80 base plus $12 per worker) adds multi-state payroll, time tracking, and deeper HR tools; Premium ($180 base plus $22) adds dedicated support and compliance depth. Your Gusto price grows by climbing tiers as much as by hiring. OnPay is a single plan: the price you see includes multi-state payroll and the full feature set, so your OnPay price grows only when your team does. Businesses certain they will stay in one state and small can take either; businesses expecting to hire across state lines should price Gusto at the Plus tier ($200 a month at 10 workers) against OnPay's $109 before deciding the tie is a tie.

Patriot remains the budget champion even at Full Service: $87 a month at 10 workers undercuts both rivals by $22, and at 25 workers by $37. Its trade-offs are ecosystem and polish rather than capability: fewer integrations and a plainer interface, against real money saved monthly. For a stable, single-location business with simple payroll, Patriot Full Service is the value pick of this guide.

The hidden costs nobody lists

The totals table is the floor, not the ceiling. Year-end forms and W-2 handling are included by some providers and metered by others; check before December, not during it. Workers compensation is pay-as-you-go through partners in the major platforms, which is convenient and worth comparing against your existing policy rather than assuming. Benefits administration (health, retirement) lives in the upper tiers of the ladder platforms and in add-ons elsewhere; a business planning to offer benefits in year two should price year two's tier today. Garnishments, multiple pay schedules, and contractor payments each have their own small print. And the largest hidden cost is switching: payroll migrations are safest at year end, when year-to-date totals reset, so a wrong choice made in March is a choice you live with until January.

Setup done right: the unglamorous checklist

Payroll setup errors echo for a year, so the boring list matters. Register for your state withholding and unemployment accounts before the first run, because the software needs the account numbers and your assigned unemployment rate. Enter every worker's withholding forms exactly as signed. Load year-to-date totals carefully if you switch mid-year, and reconcile the first run by hand against a manual calculation for one worker of each type. Set the pay schedule and then defend it: off-cycle runs and corrections are where fees and errors breed. None of this is software's job to want for you; all of it is software's job to make checkable, which is what your trial should test.

Payroll inside accounting: the other route

QuickBooks sells payroll as an add-on to its accounting plans ($38 to $340 a month before payroll), which keeps wages, taxes, and the ledger in one system and one login. The convenience is real, and for businesses whose bookkeeper lives in QuickBooks it may outweigh a standalone's edge. Price it as a total: accounting plan plus payroll add-on, at your worker count, against the standalone totals in our table. Our accounting guide works the combined arithmetic for the common pairings; the rule is to never compare a bundle's teaser against a standalone's full price.

Payroll and your books: the journal habit

Payroll ends at the bank for most owners, but it should end in the books. Each run creates entries your accounting needs: gross wages as expense, employer taxes as their own expense line, and withholdings as liabilities until remitted. The major payroll platforms post these to QuickBooks and other ledgers automatically or by export, and setting that connection up once, correctly mapped to your chart of accounts, is the difference between a clean month-end and a quarterly archaeology project. Check the first two postings by hand against the payroll reports. After that, the habit runs itself, and your profit and loss starts telling the truth about labor cost, which is the number most small business decisions secretly depend on.

Related guides

Readers working through this choice usually weigh the options below next. Each one runs the same vendor checked pricing as this guide.

Frequently asked questions

What is the cheapest payroll software for a small business?

Patriot has the lowest totals at every size in our table: Basic at $29, $57, and $117 a month for 3, 10, and 25 workers, and Full Service at $52, $87, and $162. The catch is the split: Basic leaves tax filing to you. Full Service, where Patriot files, is the cheapest full-service route we priced and this guide's value pick.

Gusto or OnPay: which should I choose?

On headline price they tie exactly: $49 base plus $6 per worker, $109 a month at 10 workers. Choose OnPay for one-plan simplicity with multi-state included. Choose Gusto if you want its tier ladder and HR ecosystem, but price the tier you will actually need: Gusto Plus at 10 workers is $200 a month, which breaks the tie decisively.

What does full-service payroll mean?

The provider calculates pay, deposits withheld taxes on schedule, and files the required forms: quarterly 941s, annual 940 and W-2s, and state equivalents. You supply hours and changes; the legal filing acts are theirs. The alternative, calculation-only plans like Patriot Basic, hand the filing back to you, which is why they cost less.

How much does payroll cost for 10 employees?

At prices checked in November 2026: $109 a month with Gusto Simple or OnPay, $87 with Patriot Full Service, and $57 with Patriot Basic if you file taxes yourself. Budget beyond the sticker for year-end forms policies, workers comp arrangements, and any benefits administration, and remember that mid-year switches are painful enough that the choice usually lasts until January.

When should I switch payroll providers?

At year end, whenever possible, because year-to-date wage and tax totals reset and the migration becomes a clean start. Mid-year switches require loading accurate year-to-date figures for every worker and reconciling them, which is doable but is the single most error-prone operation in small business payroll. If your current provider is failing at filing, switch anyway and pay for help with the load; penalties outrank tidiness.

Can payroll software pay contractors too?

The major platforms can pay contractors alongside employees, typically with their own per-person pricing or included in higher tiers. Contractor payments are simpler (no withholding) but still generate year-end 1099 obligations the platform should handle. If contractors are most of your workforce, price that mix explicitly rather than assuming the employee headline covers it.

Photo credits: Pavel Danilyuk (Pexels). Photos are served from this site; follow the credit to the library page for the original.