The short answer: you may already own one of these
Microsoft Planner's basic version is included with eligible Microsoft 365 subscriptions, which means for most readers of this comparison its marginal cost is $0: the subscription is already paid, and Planner rides inside it, next to Teams, Outlook, and SharePoint. Trello is a separate bill, $5 per user per month billed annually for Standard and $10 for Premium. So the honest question is not "which tool is better" but "what exactly does Trello's bill buy that my subscription does not already include?" This article names those things as a test you can run on your own work before spending anything, then prices Trello properly for the cases where the test fails.
| If your situation is... | Pick | Why |
|---|
| Microsoft 365 shop, simple team boards, no dependencies | Planner (included) | It is already paid for; the board lives inside Teams |
| You invite clients, freelancers, or partners to boards | Trello | Guest access outside your Microsoft tenant is Trello's home ground |
| You need automation rules that move work for you | Trello Premium | Butler has no equivalent in basic Planner |
| You need timelines and premium task features inside Microsoft | Planner Plan 1 ($10) | The upgrade stays in the ecosystem at Trello Premium's price |
Costs, from our verified data set: basic Planner is included with eligible Microsoft 365 plans at $0 marginal cost; Planner Plan 1 is $10 per user per month billed annually and adds premium task and timeline features. Trello Standard is $5 per user per month billed annually ($6 monthly), Premium is $10 ($12.50 monthly), and the free plan allows up to 10 collaborators per Workspace and 10 boards per Workspace.
The capability test: run this before pricing anything
Pay for Trello only if your work fails one of these four tests inside basic Planner. Each test takes minutes on your real boards.
Test one, dependencies: does one task wait on another in a way the tool must understand? Basic Planner tracks buckets and tasks but has no true dependency chains. If your team manages blocked work in comments and memory, that is a fail.
Test two, automation: do the same card movements happen every week (assign on move, notify on due date, archive on completion)? Planner has no Butler equivalent; recurring manual choreography is a fail.
Test three, outsiders: does anyone outside your Microsoft tenant need to see or touch the board? Planner is tenant-bound. Clients and freelancers either get full guest treatment inside your Microsoft environment or get screenshots. If outsiders are routine, that is a fail.
Test four, cross-project reporting: can you answer "what is the state of all six projects" without opening six plans? Basic Planner's reporting is per-plan. A weekly hand-built roll-up is a fail.
Four passes: stop reading and use the tool you already pay for. Any fail: keep reading, because Trello's bill now has a named job.
Axis one: where the board lives
Planner lives inside Microsoft 365: plans surface in Teams channels, tasks roll into the Planner app and To Do, files sit in SharePoint, and permissions follow your tenant's groups. For a Microsoft organization this embeddedness is the feature: no new account, no new login, no new place for work to hide.
Trello lives on the open web with its own accounts, which is exactly why outsiders are easy: invite an email address, set the board's visibility, done. The cost is a second home for work, outside the tenant's retention and discovery umbrella, which IT departments notice even when teams do not.
Verdict: embeddedness against openness. Regulated or Microsoft-standardized organizations weight the first; client-facing teams weight the second, heavily.
Axis two: the money, all three ways
Trello's verified totals at the seat counts small teams run:
| Seats | Trello Standard, per year | Trello Premium, per year | Planner Plan 1, per year |
|---|
| 5 | $300 | $600 | $600 |
| 15 | $900 | $1,800 | $1,800 |
| 30 | $1,800 | $3,600 | $3,600 |
And basic Planner, for any seat count: $0 marginal, because the Microsoft 365 subscription is a sunk cost your organization pays regardless. Two observations decide most budgets. First, Planner Plan 1 and Trello Premium cost exactly the same $10 per user, so the upgrade decision inside Microsoft is never about price; it is about whether premium Planner's timelines and task features close your test failures, or whether only Trello's model does. Second, Trello Standard at $5 is the cheapest way to buy the guest access and automation layer if your failures are tests two and three, and it undercuts Plan 1 by half.
Axis three: automation and Power-Ups against the Microsoft ecosystem
Butler is Trello's automation engine: rules, card buttons, and scheduled commands in near-plain English, with higher quotas on Premium. Around it sits the Power-Up directory, hundreds of integrations and field extensions that let a board grow into adjacent jobs (time tracking, CRM fields, reporting add-ons).
Planner's ecosystem play is different: it does not extend itself, it sits inside a suite that is already extended. Power Automate can move Planner data for organizations with the licensing and the skills, but that is an IT project, not a team setting. For a team lead comparing tools on a Tuesday afternoon, Trello's automation is usable today and Planner's is a roadmap item.
Verdict: if automation is your test failure, Trello Premium is the honest fix, and no Planner tier changes that this year.
Axis four: task depth and views
Premium Planner (Plan 1 and above) adds timelines, task history, and richer fields, and the new Planner experience has been consolidating Microsoft's task tools into one app. Basic Planner remains deliberately simple: buckets, labels, checklists, attachments, and a charts view per plan.
Trello's depth is lateral rather than vertical: the same cards render as board, calendar, timeline, table, and dashboard on Premium, and custom fields carry the extra data. Neither tool is a project management heavyweight; both are team task boards, and the one whose surrounding suite you already live in will feel deeper in daily use.
Verdict: inside a Microsoft day (Teams meetings, Outlook mail, SharePoint files), Planner's tasks are one click from everything. Inside a mixed-tool day, Trello's views and Power-Ups travel better.
Running both, and migration notes
Running both usually means Planner for internal Microsoft work and Trello for client-facing boards, which is defensible if the boundary is per project and written down. It fails when the same project lives in both, because two boards for one project means zero boards anyone trusts.
Migration is manual in both directions: neither tool imports the other natively in a way worth trusting. Export a Planner plan's tasks (via the plan's export to Excel where available) or walk the board and rebuild; Trello boards export as JSON, and Premium can export board data as CSV. Budget an hour per active board, rebuild only live work, and leave completed history in the old tool as a readable archive.
The verdict
Start with the tool you already own: basic Planner at $0 marginal cost passes most Microsoft 365 teams. Buy Trello when a named test fails: Standard at $5 per user for guest-friendly boards, Premium at $10 when Butler automation and the extra views are the point. Consider Planner Plan 1 at the same $10 when your failures are timelines and task depth and your organization wants everything inside the tenant. Never buy any of them before running the four tests on your real work.
Related guides
This decision rarely stands alone. The guides below cover the closest questions on the chart, each with prices checked on the vendor pages.
Frequently asked questions
Is Microsoft Planner really free with Microsoft 365?
Basic Planner is included with eligible Microsoft 365 subscriptions, so if your organization already pays for Microsoft 365, the marginal cost of using Planner is $0. Premium features live on paid tiers: Planner Plan 1 is $10 per user per month billed annually. Trello, by contrast, is always a separate bill: $5 per user per month billed annually for Standard, $10 for Premium.
What does Trello do that basic Planner cannot?
Four things decide most comparisons: true dependency handling between tasks, Butler automation rules that move and notify work for you, painless guest access for people outside your Microsoft tenant, and cross-project reporting. If none of those is a live pain, basic Planner is enough and Trello's bill buys nothing you will use.
Planner Plan 1 and Trello Premium both cost $10. Which should I choose?
Choose by ecosystem, not price, because the price is a tie. Plan 1 keeps tasks, files, permissions, and retention inside Microsoft 365 and adds premium task and timeline features. Trello Premium buys Butler automation, Power-Ups, and guest access that works for any email address. Run the capability test in this article and let your failed test pick.
Can guests and clients use Microsoft Planner?
Only inside your tenant's guest framework, which many clients find heavy: they sign in with Microsoft accounts and live under your organization's policies. Trello invites any email address to a board in seconds. For agencies and freelancers whose clients touch the board weekly, this single difference often decides the comparison.
Is it worth running Planner and Trello at the same time?
Yes, with a hard boundary: Planner for internal projects, Trello for client-facing ones, one project in exactly one tool. The setup fails when a project is mirrored in both, because the copies drift and the team stops trusting either. Write the boundary down where the team can see it.
Photo credits: Artem Podrez (Pexels). Photos are served from this site; follow the credit to the library page for the original.