The device-type wall
Every free comparison should start with the wall the reader already hit. Since 2021, LastPass Free works on one device type: computers or mobile devices, chosen by the user, with the other type locked until payment. A person with a laptop and a phone, which is to say a person, outgrows it immediately. The premium tier that removes the wall reads $36 per year in our dataset. The alternatives below are graded first on whether that wall exists, then on what else their free tiers quietly cap: seats, sharing, passkeys, TOTP, and file storage. The business side of the LastPass exit is graded in the business guide; the license side in the open source guide; and this site's wider Bitwarden free bench covers the neighboring comparison.
| Tool | Free tier's real shape | The catch |
|---|---|---|
| Bitwarden | Unlimited passwords, sync on all device types | Premium extras (TOTP in-app, storage) are $10-class upsells |
| Proton Pass | Full-featured free tier inside the Proton ecosystem | Best inside Proton; aliases are the draw |
| KeePassXC | Unlimited, local, offline, forever | Sync is your problem (your file, your cloud folder) |
| Apple Passwords | Built into Apple devices, iCloud sync | Apple-ecosystem only in practice |
| LastPass Free | One device type only | The wall this guide exists to route around |
Grading the free bench
Bitwarden free is the default answer and has been for years: unlimited passwords on unlimited devices, sync across all of them, sharing with one other user, and no trial clock. It is the free tier LastPass used to have, run by the company whose business and open source benches are graded elsewhere on this page's cluster. Its premium upsell is cheap and genuinely optional. Proton Pass free is the ecosystem answer: a strong free tier whose signature feature is email aliases (hide-my-email built into the vault), best for readers already using Proton Mail or willing to join that ecosystem, with the caveat that its deepest features assume you stay. KeePassXC is the sovereignty answer: a free, open source, local vault file (GPL-licensed, graded in the open source guide) that never touches a vendor's server; sync across devices is your own arrangement, usually a cloud folder, and that trade is the entire product decision.
Apple Passwords is the quiet answer for Apple-only households: built into iOS and macOS, synced through iCloud, passkey-capable, and free in the sense that the devices were not. It is a real password manager now, with sharing groups, and its limit is the ecosystem wall rather than any cap. NordPass offers a limited free tier as well; its paid prices are carried as null in our dataset because promotional reads conflict ($3.99, $4.99, and $5.49 all appear), so the free tier is noted here without a paid comparison figure attached.
The comparison tool below puts Bitwarden, Proton Pass, and LastPass side by side from the dataset so the device wall is visible in the plans themselves; the checklist audits any free tier against your real usage before you migrate a decade of logins into it.
