Why this query exists
Obsidian's deal is generous: a free, powerful, local-first app whose notes are plain Markdown files on your disk. The one thing it is not is open source. Its code is proprietary, which means your knowledge base's reader is a closed product from a small company, and if that company changes direction, your files survive but your workflow's engine does not. For most users that is an acceptable trade. For the readers of this query, it is the whole point: they want the guarantee that the tool reading their life's notes can be inspected, forked, and carried on by its community. That guarantee has a name and a text, and it is the license.
Two tests therefore grade this bench. The license test asks whether the code is genuinely open under an OSI-recognized license, stated exactly. The vault test asks what happens to your existing Obsidian vault on day one: does the tool open the folder as it lies, or does it import your notes into a database of its own? Both tests matter, and they do not always agree, which is why this guide runs both.
The bench
| Tool | License | The vault test | Shape |
|---|---|---|---|
| Logseq | AGPL-3.0 | Opens your Markdown folder unchanged | Outliner, journal-first |
| Zettlr | GPL-3.0 | Opens your Markdown folder unchanged | Editor, academic writing |
| Joplin | AGPL-3.0 | Imports into its own database | Notebook hierarchy, best sync story |
| SiYuan | AGPL-3.0 | Imports into its own block store | Block references, self-hostable |
| TriliumNext | AGPL-3.0 | Imports into its own database | Tree knowledge base, self-hosted |
| Notesnook | GPL-3.0 | Imports into its own encrypted store | Private notebook with E2EE sync |
| SilverBullet | MIT | Works on your Markdown folder | Programmable notes in the browser |
| Anytype | Source-available (not OSI) | Its own object store | Local-first workspace, peer-to-peer |
Logseq is the closest open source relative to Obsidian's daily feel: local files, backlinks, a graph, and a journal-first outliner shape, under AGPL-3.0. Its honest caveats are sync maturity (official sync has been in beta) and an outliner's bias: everything is a bullet until you learn to think in blocks. Zettlr is the writer's answer, a GPL-3.0 Markdown editor with Zettelkasten linking and citation support that treats your vault as a folder of documents rather than a database; academics leaving Obsidian land here most happily. Joplin (AGPL-3.0) is the pragmatic one: a notebook tree closer to Evernote's shape than Obsidian's graph, with the best free sync story in this guide (graded fully in the free sync Obsidian alternatives guide) paid for by importing your notes into its own database. SiYuan (AGPL-3.0) is the power tool: block-level references and self-hosting, with notes in its own block store and a one-time $64 PRO membership instead of a subscription. TriliumNext, the living fork of Trilium, is the self-hosted tree archive. Notesnook (GPL-3.0) is the privacy specialist, end-to-end encrypted sync on its free plan. SilverBullet (MIT) is the hacker's notebook, programmable and folder-native.
And the correction this guide owes you: Anytype is excellent and local-first, but its license is its own source-available terms, not an OSI open source license. It belongs on a local-first list, not this one, and guides that file it under open source are rounding in the vendor's favor.
