Smartsheet Alternatives in Microsoft 365: The Tenant Bench
By the SoftSea editorial team
Photo: Christina Morillo / Pexels
You may already own most of the replacement
Smartsheet sells a grid, workflows, and reporting to companies that, in a Microsoft 365 tenant, already pay for overlapping parts: Planner runs task boards, Lists runs structured data with views and rules, and Power Automate moves work between them and everything else in the tenant. The tenant bench therefore grades differently from the general Smartsheet bench: not which product is best, but which Smartsheet jobs your existing licenses already cover, which jobs need a paid Microsoft tier, and which jobs genuinely require leaving the tenant. Per-seat Smartsheet math (Pro at $12 per user per month billed annually in the dataset) only matters for the jobs the tenant cannot absorb.
Smartsheet job
Tenant answer
What to verify
Task boards and plans
Microsoft Planner
Plan limits and premium features by license
Structured lists and tracking grids
Microsoft Lists
View, rules, and column depth vs your sheet design
Cross-app automation
Power Automate
Included flows vs premium connectors
Portfolio reporting
Power BI (tenant licenses vary)
Whether your tier includes publishing and sharing
Planner after the 2025 fold: one surface, two depths
Microsoft folded Project for the web into Planner in 2025, so Planner is now a single surface with two depths: the basic plans included with Microsoft 365, and premium plans (Planner Plan 1, and Planner and Project Plan 3 in the dataset) that add the project-management depth, timelines, dependencies, and goals that used to live in the separate product. For Smartsheet migrants the grading question is precise: which of your sheets are really task plans wearing a grid (Planner absorbs those), and which are data tables with rollups (Lists' shape instead). The calculator below models Smartsheet's own per-seat cost from the dataset; compare it against the premium Planner seats only for the users who need the depth, because basic Planner seats are already inside licenses the company owns.
Interactive tool
Comparison Builder
Pick two or three products and see them side by side on the numbers that decide the purchase.
Measure
Smartsheet
Microsoft Planner
Microsoft Lists
Starting paid price
$9 per user/mo, billed annually
$10 per user/mo, billed annually
$7 per user/mo, billed annually
Free option
No free plan: 30-day trial, no credit card required
No standalone free plan: basic Planner is included with eligible Microsoft 365 subscriptions
No standalone free plan: Lists is included with Microsoft 365 plans that include SharePoint
Plans
Pro: $9/user/mo annual · Business: $19/user/mo annual · Enterprise: not published
Included with Microsoft 365: free · Planner Plan 1: $10/user/mo annual · Planner and Project Plan 3: not published
Included with Microsoft 365 Business Basic: $7/user/mo annual · Included with Microsoft 365 Business Standard: $14/user/mo annual
Platforms
Web, iOS, Android
Web, iOS, Android
Web, Windows, macOS
Best for
PMOs and operations teams, schedule-driven projects, spreadsheet natives who need governance
Microsoft 365 organizations, simple team task boards, departments that live in Teams
Microsoft 365 companies tracking assets, issues, and inventory, teams that want no new vendor or bill, regulated tenants that need data inside SharePoint
Strengths
Real spreadsheet depth: formulas, cross-sheet references, critical path; Gantt and schedule discipline from the entry tier; Roll-up reports and dashboards for portfolio reporting
Already paid for in most Microsoft 365 organizations; Lives inside Teams, where the conversations already happen; Almost no learning curve for Microsoft users
Marginal cost is $0 inside a Microsoft 365 subscription already paid; Holds up to 30 million items per list per Microsoft documentation, far beyond Airtable base caps; Permissions, retention, and compliance are the tenant settings IT already manages
Watch out for
No free plan, only a trial; Resource management and premium connectors are paid add-ons; Task handoffs and comments are weaker than task-first tools
Basic plans lack true dependencies and cross-project reporting; Weak outside the Microsoft ecosystem; Premium features are spread across confusing plan tiers
No linked records at Airtable depth; relations are lookups, not a relational model; The iOS and Android Lists apps were retired in November 2025, so mobile work runs through Teams and SharePoint; Automations usually mean Power Automate, a second tool to learn
Lowest entry price: Microsoft Lists at $7 per user/mo billed annually. None of these has a real free plan, only trials. Entry price is the floor, not the decision: check the plan line above for the tier that actually includes the feature you need.
All figures from vendor pricing pages, checked November 18, 2026. Some vendors price by contacts, tasks, or operations instead of seats; those notes are in the plan data and the linked pricing guides.
Project Online's retirement date is a planning fact
Project Online retires on September 30, 2026. Any tenant still running portfolio structure on Project Online is on a countdown, and any Smartsheet evaluation inside such a tenant is really a two-system migration evaluated as one. The date matters for grading: Microsoft's own roadmap pushes that work toward Planner's premium surface and Project Server Subscription Edition for the on-premises holdouts. If your Smartsheet exit and your Project Online exit are the same project, say so in the plan, because the combined migration is cheaper than two sequential ones and the September 2026 date is not negotiable. Vendor roadmap dates can move; verify this one on Microsoft's lifecycle pages when you plan, and treat the direction, consolidation into Planner, as settled even if the day shifts.
Lists and Power Automate: the grid and the glue
Lists is the tenant's honest grid answer: structured tables with column types, views, formatting rules, and alerts, included with Microsoft 365. It absorbs tracking sheets, registers, and status tables well; it is not a formula-heavy financial grid, and Smartsheet sheets built on deep cross-sheet formulas will not translate cell for cell. Power Automate is the glue that makes the stack behave like one product: approvals, notifications, and data movement between Planner, Lists, Teams, and the rest of the tenant, with the familiar caveat that premium connectors are a paid tier. Grade the stack as a stack. Individually, each piece loses a shootout to Smartsheet's integrated grid; together, inside a tenant already paying for them, they cover the majority of real Smartsheet workloads at zero marginal license cost.
What the tenant stack cannot do
Honesty cuts the other way too. Smartsheet's cross-sheet formula depth, its resource management, and its single-surface portfolio rollups are genuinely ahead of a Planner plus Lists assembly, and external collaborator access is clumsier inside tenant boundaries than in a tool built for guests. If your Smartsheet usage is concentrated in those strengths, the tenant bench's verdict is to keep Smartsheet for that workload and absorb only the task and tracking jobs into the tenant. Partial migration is a respectable outcome; the failure mode is forcing the last 20 percent into tools that bend, to save seats that were never the real cost.
The verdict
Task plans and boards: Planner, basic where it suffices, premium seats only where depth is proven. Tracking grids and registers: Lists. Glue: Power Automate, with premium connectors budgeted where they are actually used. Portfolio work still on Project Online: plan its exit before September 30, 2026, and combine it with the Smartsheet decision. Deep grid workloads with heavy external collaboration: keep Smartsheet and narrow its seat count to the people doing that work. The tenant bench rarely ends at zero Smartsheet seats; it ends at the right number.
Interactive tool
The tenant absorption checklist
Check off each step as you finish it. Your progress stays on this page.
0 of 5 complete
0% done
Related guides
More from this corner of the chart: these companion guides compare the nearest alternatives and head to head matchups.
There is no single one; the tenant answer is a stack: Planner for task plans, Lists for structured tracking, and Power Automate for workflow glue, all inside Microsoft 365 licenses. Together they absorb most task and tracking workloads; deep cross-sheet formula work remains Smartsheet's strength.
Is Project Online being retired?
Yes. Microsoft has set Project Online's retirement for September 30, 2026, following the 2025 fold of Project for the web into Planner. Tenants should verify the date on Microsoft's lifecycle pages when planning and treat Planner's premium surface as the destination for that work.
How much does Smartsheet cost compared with Planner?
Smartsheet Pro is $12 per user per month billed annually in the dataset ($15 billed monthly). Basic Planner is included with Microsoft 365 business licenses many tenants already own; premium Planner tiers are separate per-user plans. The honest comparison prices Smartsheet seats against only the premium Planner seats your workload proves it needs.
Can Microsoft Lists replace Smartsheet sheets?
For tracking grids, registers, and status tables, largely yes: Lists provides structured columns, views, rules, and alerts inside the tenant. Sheets built on deep cross-sheet formulas and rollups do not translate cell for cell, and that class of sheet is the honest exception.
Should we migrate everything off Smartsheet into Microsoft 365?
Usually not everything. The tenant stack absorbs task plans and tracking well; Smartsheet's formula depth, resource management, and guest collaboration are real strengths. The strong outcome is a narrowed Smartsheet seat count for the workloads that need it, not a forced total exit.
Photo credits: Christina Morillo (Pexels). Photos are served from this site; follow the credit to the library page for the original.