Home / Software Alternatives

Gusto Alternatives: The Exit Guide, From Like-for-Like Payroll to PEO and Global Hiring

Multiethnic cheerful colleagues looking at stickers and smiling in an office.

Photo: Anna Shvets / Pexels

The premise: price the shape of Gusto's bill before shopping

Most Gusto exits start with a surprise, and the surprise is arithmetic. Gusto charges a base fee plus a per-person fee on every tier, so the advertised $6 per person on Simple is a $55 monthly floor for a one-person company, and Plus's $12 per person sits on an $80 base. At five employees, Simple is $79 a month and Plus is $140; at twenty, $169 and $320. None of that makes Gusto bad software: automatic federal, state, and local tax filing, unlimited runs, and employee self-service are genuinely good, and the base fee buys real compliance machinery. It makes the exit a pricing-shape decision. Readers leave for four reasons: the floor is too high for a tiny payroll, the company needs a PEO's benefits pool, the company has outgrown payroll into IT and HR platform territory, or the next hire is in another country. Each reason has a different correct destination, and the incumbent lists that rank one mixed bench for all four produce expensive mistakes, like moving a five-person US team onto an employer-of-record contract priced for international hiring.

Why you are leavingDestinationTerms in our dataset
Same job, cleaner pricingOnPay$6 per worker plus $49 base, one plan, multi-state included
Smallest possible billPatriotBudget tier in our dataset; filing depth varies by tier
Benefits through a PEOJustworks PEO Basic$79 per employee, no base fee
Outgrew payroll into a platformRipplingFrom $8 per user plus base in vendor reads; modules quoted
Hiring in another countryDeel EOR$599 per employee per month

The payroll-shaped exits: OnPay and Patriot

OnPay is the like-for-like answer and the one most Gusto leavers actually need: a single plan at $6 per worker plus a $49 base fee, with multi-state filing included at that price, where Gusto reserves multi-state payroll for Plus at $12 per person plus $80. A five-person multi-state team pays $79 a month on OnPay against $140 on Gusto Plus, and the feature story (full-service filing, onboarding, benefits administration) is comparable for a standard small-business payroll. Patriot serves the budget exit, with a cheaper entry shape in our dataset and filing depth that varies by tier, so the honest advice is to price the tier that includes the tax filing you actually need rather than the headline tier. This flagship deliberately stops at the platform boundary: the detailed payroll-only bench, per-state fees, contractor-only plans, and filing-by-filing comparison live in the Gusto payroll alternatives guide, which excludes the PEO, EOR, and platform destinations graded here.

Interactive tool

Comparison Builder

Pick two or three products and see them side by side on the numbers that decide the purchase.

MeasureGustoOnPayRippling
Starting paid price$6 per user/mo, billed annually$6 per user/mo, billed annually$8 per user/mo, billed annually
Free optionNo free plan; month-to-month pricing with no long-term contractNo free plan; one plan, no tiersNo free plan; pricing is modular and partly quote-based
PlansSimple: $6/user/mo annual · Plus: $12/user/mo annual · Premium: $22/user/mo annualPayroll: $6/user/mo annualCore platform: $8/user/mo annual
PlatformsWeb, iOS, AndroidWebWeb, iOS, Android
Best forsmall teams hiring W-2 employees, owners who want payroll taxes handled, businesses adding benefitsmulti-state small employers, businesses that hate tier ladders, niche industries with mixed W-2 and 1099 staffcompanies past 50 employees, IT and HR teams merging workflows, multi-country employers
StrengthsAutomatic federal, state, and local tax filing on every plan; Unlimited payroll runs; Employee self-service and benefits access includedOne plan, so no tier upsell; Multi-state tax filing included at the single price; Onboarding and benefits administration includedPayroll, devices, and apps managed from one system; Automation across onboarding and offboarding; Scales further than any payroll-first rival
Watch out forThe base fee means a one-person payroll still costs $55 a month on Simple; Multi-state payroll needs Plus; Add-ons (priority support, state registration) raise the billBase fee makes tiny payrolls cost the same to start as Gusto Simple; Smaller integration ecosystem than the biggest payroll brands; HR extras are add-onsReal cost needs a quote; the starting figure buys little alone; Module pricing stacks up fast; Heavier than a small team’s payroll problem

Lowest entry price: Gusto at $6 per user/mo billed annually. None of these has a real free plan, only trials. Entry price is the floor, not the decision: check the plan line above for the tier that actually includes the feature you need.

All figures from vendor pricing pages, checked November 18, 2026. Some vendors price by contacts, tasks, or operations instead of seats; those notes are in the plan data and the linked pricing guides.

The step-up exits: Justworks, Rippling, and Deel

Justworks is the destination when the exit reason is benefits rather than payroll mechanics. Its own payroll product ($50 base plus $8 per employee in our dataset) is a lateral move; the real step is its PEO, where Justworks becomes the co-employer and your team joins its benefits pool, at $79 per employee per month for PEO Basic with no base fee. That is a step change in price and in legal structure, and it should be bought for the benefits access, never as a payroll upgrade. Rippling is the platform exit: payroll, HR, IT device management, and spend on one employee record, with published starting figures from $8 per user plus a base in vendor reads and most modules quoted, which means the real price requires a sales conversation and the honest dataset entry says so. Deel is the international exit: its EOR product, at $599 per employee per month, makes Deel the legal employer in countries where you have no entity, and its contractor management runs $49 per contractor per month. Quoting Deel against Gusto is a category error unless the hire is genuinely cross-border. UK readers have a separate problem entirely, because Gusto does not run UK domestic payroll at all; that premise correction and the UK-native bench are graded in the Gusto alternatives for the UK guide.

Interactive tool

SaaS Cost Calculator

The per-seat price is the small number. This is the real one: your team, a full year, both billing cycles.

Gusto Simple for 10 seats

$720.00 per year

Billed annually: $60.00 per month equivalent, paid once a year.

Billed monthly instead: $720.00 per year.

No annual discount on these figures, so monthly billing costs nothing extra and keeps you free to leave.

Bar: annual-billing cost as a share of monthly-billing cost for the same seats.

Plan prices from vendor pricing pages, checked November 18, 2026. Taxes, add-ons, and usage overages are not included, because vendors do not include them in the headline price either.

How to leave Gusto without a payroll incident

Payroll migrations fail at quarter boundaries and year boundaries, so timing is the discipline. Switch at a quarter start where possible, and never mid-quarter if your current provider has already filed: the new provider needs year-to-date wages, taxes withheld, and employer contributions for every employee, and Gusto's reports supply them if you export before closing the account. Run one parallel payroll in the new system and compare net pay to the cent before the first live run. Confirm who files the final returns for the transition quarter in writing; duplicate filings and missing filings both trace back to that ambiguity. The seat calculator on this page prices Gusto's tiers against the switch for your headcount; for teams under ten with single-state payroll, the math usually says OnPay or staying, and for teams whose real problem is benefits or borders, the payroll price was never the problem to solve.

Related guides

Readers working through this choice usually weigh the options below next. Each one runs the same vendor checked pricing as this guide.

Frequently asked questions

What is the best alternative to Gusto?

OnPay for most small teams: one plan at $6 per worker plus a $49 base fee, with multi-state filing included, where Gusto charges $12 per person plus an $80 base for multi-state on Plus. Step-up exits differ: Justworks for PEO benefits, Rippling for a platform, Deel for international hires.

Why is my Gusto bill higher than the per-person price?

Because every Gusto tier adds a monthly base fee: $49 on Simple, $80 on Plus, $180 on Premium, on top of the per-person fee. A one-person payroll on Simple costs $55 a month in total. The calculator on this page runs the full shape for your headcount.

Is OnPay really cheaper than Gusto?

For multi-state teams, usually yes: OnPay includes multi-state filing in its single $6 per worker plus $49 base plan, while Gusto's multi-state tier is Plus at $12 per person plus $80 base. Single-state teams should run both shapes at their exact headcount.

When should I choose a PEO like Justworks instead?

When the goal is big-company benefits access through co-employment, not cheaper payroll. Justworks PEO Basic is $79 per employee per month with no base fee, a step change in price and legal structure that should be bought for benefits alone.

Can Gusto run payroll outside the United States?

Gusto is a US payroll platform. International employees are handled through partner employer-of-record arrangements at EOR pricing (Deel's EOR, for comparison, is $599 per employee per month), and Gusto does not run UK domestic payroll; the UK guide on this site grades that case separately.

Photo credits: Anna Shvets (Pexels). Photos are served from this site; follow the credit to the library page for the original.