Gusto Payroll Alternatives: The Payroll-Only Bench, Filing, Multi-State, and Contractor Plans
By the SoftSea editorial team
Photo: Tima Miroshnichenko / Pexels
The scope rule: payroll questions only
The search results for this query and for "Gusto alternatives" are nearly the same lists, and both make the same category error: they rank PEOs, global EOR platforms, and HR suites inside a payroll comparison, where those products win on features the payroll reader never asked about while their actual payroll mechanics go unexamined. This guide draws the line the flagship does not. The general Gusto alternatives guide owns the whole platform decision, including Justworks' PEO, Rippling's platform, and Deel's EOR. This page owns the payroll bench alone, and grades four questions per product: who files federal, state, and local taxes and at which tier, how multi-state payroll is priced, what per-state or per-filing fees hide under the headline price, and how contractor payments are handled. If your problem is benefits, borders, or platforms, you are in the wrong guide and the flagship will serve you better.
Product
Price shape in our dataset
Multi-state treatment
OnPay
$6 per worker plus $49 base, one plan
Included in the single plan
Gusto Simple
$6 per person plus $49 base
Single-state only
Gusto Plus
$12 per person plus $80 base
Multi-state included at this tier
Patriot
Budget tiers in our dataset
Filing depth varies by tier; check the tier you price
Square Payroll
$6 per person plus $35 base
Suited to hourly, tip-heavy teams on Square
Filing and the multi-state boundary
Tax filing is the payroll product; everything else is interface. OnPay's single-plan shape is the cleanest answer on this bench: one plan, full-service filing, and multi-state included, so a team that hires its second-state employee mid-year has no tier event at all. Gusto draws the boundary at Plus: Simple is single-state, and the day a remote hire lands in a second state, the bill moves from $6 per person plus $49 to $12 per person plus $80, a jump of $31 in base fees alone before the per-person doubling. That boundary, not the headline per-person price, is the number multi-state teams should compare, and it is the number the incumbent lists consistently bury. Patriot's bench position is price: its entry shape undercuts both, but filing depth varies by tier, and a payroll whose cheapest tier makes you file your own taxes is not the same product as a full-service tier at a higher price; compare like for like. Square Payroll ($35 base plus $6 per person) earns its place for hourly teams whose hours and tips already live in Square POS, where the integration removes a whole class of timesheet errors, and its HR depth is thinner than Gusto's, which on this payroll-only bench is a smaller sin than it sounds.
Interactive tool
Comparison Builder
Pick two or three products and see them side by side on the numbers that decide the purchase.
Measure
Gusto
OnPay
Square Payroll
Starting paid price
$6 per user/mo, billed annually
$6 per user/mo, billed annually
$6 per user/mo, billed annually
Free option
No free plan; month-to-month pricing with no long-term contract
small teams hiring W-2 employees, owners who want payroll taxes handled, businesses adding benefits
multi-state small employers, businesses that hate tier ladders, niche industries with mixed W-2 and 1099 staff
restaurants and retail on Square, hourly teams with tips, very small employers
Strengths
Automatic federal, state, and local tax filing on every plan; Unlimited payroll runs; Employee self-service and benefits access included
One plan, so no tier upsell; Multi-state tax filing included at the single price; Onboarding and benefits administration included
Tips and hours flow straight from Square POS; Same-day pay options for hourly staff; Simple single-plan pricing
Watch out for
The base fee means a one-person payroll still costs $55 a month on Simple; Multi-state payroll needs Plus; Add-ons (priority support, state registration) raise the bill
Base fee makes tiny payrolls cost the same to start as Gusto Simple; Smaller integration ecosystem than the biggest payroll brands; HR extras are add-ons
Best inside the Square ecosystem only; HR depth is thinner than Gusto or Rippling; Base fee still applies at one employee
Lowest entry price: Gusto at $6 per user/mo billed annually. None of these has a real free plan, only trials. Entry price is the floor, not the decision: check the plan line above for the tier that actually includes the feature you need.
All figures from vendor pricing pages, checked November 18, 2026. Some vendors price by contacts, tasks, or operations instead of seats; those notes are in the plan data and the linked pricing guides.
The contractor trap and per-state fees
Two traps recur in this category and both appear in current reads of Gusto's own terms. First, contractor-only plans: businesses that pay only 1099 contractors have historically used cheap contractor-only payroll tiers, and Gusto's contractor-only plan closed to new customers on October 1, 2026 in current reads, so a comparison written before that date recommends a product a new customer cannot buy. Verify any contractor-only recommendation against the vendor's current page, ours included, before budgeting on it. Second, per-state and setup fees: some payroll pricing adds state registration, new-hire reporting, or per-filing charges that never appear in the per-person headline, and the only defense is reading the fee schedule of the exact plan you are buying. The calculator on this page runs OnPay's single-plan shape against your headcount as the reference case; run Gusto's two shapes beside it (Simple if you are certain you are single-state, Plus if there is any chance you are not) and the tier boundary prices itself.
Interactive tool
SaaS Cost Calculator
The per-seat price is the small number. This is the real one: your team, a full year, both billing cycles.
OnPay Payroll for 10 seats
$720.00 per year
Billed annually: $60.00 per month equivalent, paid once a year.
Billed monthly instead: $720.00 per year.
No annual discount on these figures, so monthly billing costs nothing extra and keeps you free to leave.
Bar: annual-billing cost as a share of monthly-billing cost for the same seats.
Plan prices from vendor pricing pages, checked November 18, 2026. Taxes, add-ons, and usage overages are not included, because vendors do not include them in the headline price either.
The verdict by payroll shape
Single-plan simplicity and multi-state safety point to OnPay for most payroll-only switchers. The smallest bill points to Patriot, provided the tier you price includes the filing you need. Hourly, tip-heavy teams already running Square should price Square Payroll's $35 base shape before anything else, because the POS integration is worth more than a small price difference. Staying on Gusto Simple is defensible for a stable single-state team that values its interface and benefits access; the indefensible move is drifting onto Plus pricing by accident because a second-state hire arrived and nobody re-ran the comparison. And if the evaluation keeps surfacing benefits, global hiring, or device management, the question has stopped being payroll-only: the general Gusto alternatives guide grades those destinations, and UK readers have a premise problem of their own handled in the UK guide.
Related guides
Readers working through this choice usually weigh the options below next. Each one runs the same vendor checked pricing as this guide.
What is the cheapest full-service alternative to Gusto payroll?
OnPay is the reference case: $6 per worker plus a $49 base fee on a single plan with multi-state filing included. Patriot can undercut it at entry tiers, but confirm the tier you price includes full tax filing, since filing depth varies by tier.
Why does multi-state payroll cost more on Gusto?
Because Gusto draws the line at tiers: Simple ($6 per person plus $49 base) is single-state, and multi-state requires Plus ($12 per person plus $80 base). OnPay includes multi-state in its single plan, which is why the comparison flips for distributed teams.
Can I still buy Gusto's contractor-only plan?
Current reads say no: Gusto's contractor-only plan closed to new customers on October 1, 2026. Contractor-heavy businesses should verify the current vendor page and price full plans or contractor payment features inside OnPay and Patriot instead.
Is Square Payroll a real Gusto competitor?
For hourly teams on Square, yes: $35 base plus $6 per person, with hours and tips flowing from Square POS. Its HR depth is thinner than Gusto's, so it wins on payroll mechanics for that specific team shape.
What is the difference between this guide and the general Gusto alternatives guide?
Scope. This guide grades payroll only: filing, multi-state pricing, fees, and contractor handling. The general guide owns the platform decision, including PEO co-employment (Justworks), platforms (Rippling), and global EOR hiring (Deel), which are excluded here on purpose.
Photo credits: Tima Miroshnichenko (Pexels). Photos are served from this site; follow the credit to the library page for the original.