The owner's arithmetic
Marketing-platform comparisons assume a reader who sends weekly campaigns and A/B tests subject lines for sport. The small business reader sends twice a month, built the list from a clipboard and a Square terminal, and considers email a success if the phone rings. For that reader, three numbers decide everything: the monthly bill at their real list size, the hours to the first respectable email, and the penalty when the list grows past a tier boundary mid-season. Mailchimp's shape fails this reader specifically: per-contact billing that charges for unsubscribed addresses, audiences that double-bill the same customer, and a free plan cut to 250 contacts that a real customer list outgrows in its first year. The bench below is graded on the owner's arithmetic, and the flagship guide covers the mechanics in full for readers who want the deep version.
| Tool | At 500 contacts | At 1,000 contacts | Setup shape | First bite |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| MailerLite | Comfort $10.80 annual | Scales by subscriber tier | Hours; clean editor | Free plan ends at 250 subscribers |
| Brevo | Starter $9 (send-based) | Still send-based | Hours; more menus | Daily send caps on free |
| Constant Contact | Lite $10.20 annual | Standard $29.75 annual | Fastest hand-holding | Price steps between tiers |
| Sender | Free to 2,500 subscribers | Free within 15,000 emails a month | Simple | Automation depth at paid tiers |
| Mailchimp | Essentials from $13 | Climbs with contacts | Familiar but busy | Unsubscribed contacts billed |
The bench for a business of one to ten
MailerLite is the default recommendation for this reader: Comfort at $10.80 per month billed annually for 500 subscribers, an editor a non-designer can produce a good-looking email in, automations that cover the welcome and abandoned-cart basics without a manual, and subscriber-based pricing that does not rent you your own unsubscribed customers. The free plan (250 subscribers, 2,500 emails after the June 2026 cut) is a starting ramp, not a home.
Brevo is the answer when the list is large relative to how often you send: a holiday business with 4,000 contacts mailed six times a year pays for sends (Starter $9 per month; free at 300 emails a day), not for storing the list. Its interface has more menus than MailerLite's, which is the honest cost of the broader platform. Constant Contact is the answer when the owner wants a human-shaped on-ramp: Lite at $10.20 per month billed annually at 500 contacts, strong event tools, and support culture aimed at beginners, with Standard at $29.75 the step to watch as needs grow. Sender is the budget answer: a free plan covering 2,500 subscribers and 15,000 emails a month covers many small businesses entirely, with paid tiers for automation depth when the day comes.
What to skip at this size: Klaviyo-grade ecommerce machinery unless online revenue is the business, ActiveCampaign-grade automation unless a specific journey earns it, and any platform whose pricing page needs a sales call. The comparison tool below prices the three most common destinations at your seat on the ladder; the checklist after it is the migration sequence (export, suppressions, first send) sized for one person doing it between customers.
