The billing mechanics are the product review
Mailchimp's feature set is broad and mostly fine, which is why feature-grid comparisons miss the story. The exit causes are arithmetic. First: Mailchimp bills on total contacts in an audience, including people who unsubscribed, so a list you have mailed for five years carries a growing tail of contacts you may not legally email but must pay to store. Archiving mitigates this and almost nobody does it on schedule. Second: audiences are silos, so the same subscriber in your newsletter audience and your store audience is two billable contacts; the platform's own structure taxes the segmentation it encourages. Third: the free tier shrank to 250 contacts, 500 monthly sends, and a 250 daily cap, which converted Free from a starting point into a demo. Fourth: the paid ladder's shape, Essentials from $13 per month and Standard from $20 at entry sizes, steepens with contact count in ways that surprise teams at renewal. Every alternative below is graded against those four mechanics, at stated list sizes, because a cheaper headline price with the same mechanics is not an alternative; it is a postponement.
| Tool | Bills on | Entry price | Free shape | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Brevo | Emails sent, not contacts | Starter $9 | 300 emails a day, 100k contacts | Lists bigger than send volume |
| MailerLite | Subscribers | Comfort $10.80 annual at 500 | 250 subscribers, 2,500 emails | Small lists, clean tooling |
| Kit | Subscribers | Free to 10,000 subscribers | Generous free newsletter tier | Creators and newsletters |
| Klaviyo | Active profiles | Email $20 at 500 contacts | Small free tier | Ecommerce revenue tooling |
| ActiveCampaign | Contacts | Starter $15 annual at 1,000 | No free plan | Automation depth |
| Constant Contact | Contacts | Lite $10.20 annual at 500 | Trial | Events and beginners |
| Sender | Subscribers | Paid tiers (not carried) | 2,500 subscribers, 15,000 emails | Budget sending at volume |
The bench, graded on the mechanics
Brevo is the structural answer to the first mechanic: it prices primarily on emails sent, with contacts up to 100,000 stored on the free plan and 300 emails a day at $0, so a large, slowly-mailed list stops being a liability. Starter at $9 per month covers most switchers. If your pain is paying rent on unsubscribed contacts, Brevo's model is the direct negation of it. MailerLite is the cleanliness answer: subscriber-based pricing that starts at $10.80 per month billed annually for 500 subscribers on Comfort, an interface that respects beginners, and a free plan (250 subscribers, 2,500 emails after its June 2026 cut) that is honest about being small. It bills on subscribers rather than total stored contacts in the Mailchimp sense, and its single-list structure discourages the duplicate-audience tax by design.
Kit is the creator answer: a free tier to 10,000 subscribers that makes it the default landing spot for newsletter-first senders, graded fully in the newsletters guide. Klaviyo is the ecommerce answer, priced from $20 per month at 500 contacts, worth it when revenue attribution per flow pays for the platform, wasteful when it does not. ActiveCampaign (Starter $15 billed annually at 1,000 contacts) is the automation answer for teams whose Mailchimp journeys felt like toys. Constant Contact (Lite $10.20 billed annually at 500 contacts) is the hand-holding answer, strong for events and beginners, priced in full in the comparison below. Sender's free plan (2,500 subscribers, 15,000 emails monthly) is the most generous free shape in this table for pure sending.
Regional and structural variants have their own guides on this site, because their benches do not overlap this one: Canada for CASL and residency, Europe for EU data residency, the UK guide for PECR and UK senders, nonprofits for verified discounts, small business for the no-marketer bench, and open source for the self-hosted stack.
