The method: read the repo like a maintainer
A GitHub search returns a popularity contest. Stars measure how many people once clicked a button; they do not measure whether anyone merged a pull request this quarter. Since an open source notes app is a multi-year commitment (your knowledge base will live in it), this guide grades three repository facts instead. First, the license file: it must exist in the repo and say what the roundups claim it says. Second, recency: commits inside the last twelve months, the simplest living-or-dead test there is. Third, lineage: whether the repository in front of you is the project's living line, a stale original, or an archive. Every verdict below was checked against the repositories themselves in November 2026, and the dates are printed so you can re-run the check in a year and grade this guide the same way.
The findings that shape the bench
Dendron is de facto abandoned. The VS Code-based notes project was a serious Obsidian rival, and its repository's last commits date to June 2025. A knowledge base tool that has stopped moving is not a foundation; it is a future migration. Reor was archived in March 2026. The AI-first notes app is read-only in the way that matters: archived repositories accept no future. The original Trilium is in maintenance mode, and TriliumNext is the living line. This is the instructive case, because it shows lineage done right: a community fork carrying the project forward under the same AGPL-3.0 license, with the original's blessing implied by the handover. Search results still surface the original first, which is exactly why lineage is a grading axis.
The living bench
| Project | License in repo | Health signal (checked November 2026) | Shape |
|---|---|---|---|
| Logseq | AGPL-3.0 | Active development | Outliner on Markdown files |
| Joplin | AGPL-3.0 | Active, large community | Notebooks, best sync options |
| SiYuan | AGPL-3.0 | Active releases | Block references, self-hostable |
| TriliumNext | AGPL-3.0 | The living Trilium fork | Tree knowledge base, self-hosted |
| SilverBullet | MIT | Active | Programmable Markdown notes |
| Zettlr | GPL-3.0 | Active | Academic Markdown writing |
| Notesnook | GPL-3.0 | Active | Encrypted notebook |
| Dendron | Apache-2.0 | Last commits June 2025: de facto abandoned | Do not start here |
| Reor | Open source | Archived March 2026 | Do not start here |
The bench's center of gravity is AGPL-3.0, and the license reading from the open source Obsidian alternatives bench applies unchanged: the network clause binds service operators, not note takers. What this guide adds is the pulse check. Logseq, Joplin, and SiYuan are the three with the deepest benches of contributors and the steadiest release rhythms, which is why they anchor most shortlists; SilverBullet's MIT license makes it the permissive outlier; TriliumNext is the proof that a fork can be the healthiest address in a category.
A word about star counts, since this query's readers arrive holding them: treat stars as a tiebreaker between two living projects, never as evidence of life. Dendron's star count did not protect its users. The commit graph is the vital sign; the star count is the yearbook photo.
