Home / Software Alternatives

ItsDeductible Alternatives: Replacing a Product Intuit Shut Down

Volunteers distributing donated goods at an outdoor donation center.

Photo: RDNE Stock project / Pexels

A shutdown bench: what actually died on October 21, 2025

ItsDeductible was a small, beloved tool: it tracked cash and noncash charitable donations through the year and, crucially, valued donated goods (clothing, furniture, household items) at defensible fair market values, then handed the totals to TurboTax at filing time. Intuit shut it down on October 21, 2025. What died was not the deduction (noncash charitable contributions remain deductible for itemizers under the same rules) but the workflow: the year-round log, the valuation tables, and the clean handoff. This bench grades replacements on those three jobs, and it prints two facts the replacement lists underplay. First, TurboTax Online accepts no TXF file from any tracker, so the classic export path pays only inside TurboTax Desktop. Second, by March 2026 TurboTax Online had added a built-in fair market value tool per Intuit's own help text, which means some refugees need no replacement at all. Both facts change the verdict by reader, which is what a bench is for.

TrackerPrice shape (current reads)Import of ItsDeductible dataExport shapeDeciding strength
Deductible DuckFree for the first $1,000 in donations; then $29.99 per yearBuilt for the ItsDeductible exit shapeTXF export for TurboTax DesktopPurpose-built replacement with valuation guidance
DeductAbleSubscription trackerImports ItsDeductible CSV exportsTXF exportThe import path is the headline feature
ItsDeducted$29 per yearMigration-shaped onboardingTracker exportNamed for the refugee it serves
Charity RecordFree up to $500 in donationsManual entry shapeRecords and summariesThe free light-duty option
TurboTax Online built-in toolIncluded in TurboTax OnlineManual re-entry of this year's giftsNative, no file neededNo new product at all, for Online filers

Deductible Duck and DeductAble: the purpose-built pair

Deductible Duck is the replacement shaped most directly at the vacancy: donation logging with valuation guidance, free for the first $1,000 in donations tracked and $29.99 per year beyond that in current reads, with TXF export aimed at TurboTax Desktop. For a household that donates goods regularly and files with TurboTax Desktop, it restores the old workflow almost exactly. DeductAble makes the import its headline: it imports ItsDeductible CSV exports, which matters more than any feature if your history survived as a file, and it exports TXF on the same Desktop-only terms. The adjudication between them is your data's shape: years of history in a CSV argues DeductAble; a fresh start with heavy ongoing donations argues Deductible Duck's free first $1,000 and valuation depth. The comparison below puts Deductible Duck, TurboTax, and H&R Block side by side from the dataset, because the filing destination decides whether any tracker's export is worth anything to you.

Interactive tool

Comparison Builder

Pick two or three products and see them side by side on the numbers that decide the purchase.

MeasureDeductible DuckTurboTaxH&R Block
Starting paid priceNot published$79 per month, flat$65 per month, flat
Free optionFree plan: free for the first 1,000 dollars in donations trackedFree plan: Free Edition is $0 federal and state for simple Form 1040 returns only (no itemizing, no investments, no Schedule C)Free plan: Free Online is $0 federal and $0 state for simple returns, and covers more forms than TurboTax Free Edition
PlansTracker: not publishedDeluxe (Online, Do It Yourself): $79/mo flat · Premium (Online, Do It Yourself): $139/mo flat · Expert Assist Premium: $209/mo flatDeluxe (Online): $65/mo flat · Premium (Online): $105/mo flat · Self-Employed (Online): $130/mo flat
PlatformsWeb, iOS, AndroidWeb, Windows, macOS, iOS, AndroidWeb, Windows, iOS, Android
Best forItsDeductible users with years of donation history, households donating goods regularly, TurboTax Desktop filers who itemizefilers who want maximum hand-holding, complex returns with many imports, users who value expert accessfilers who want a big brand for less, returns that may need office backup, itemizers and investors
StrengthsPurpose-built for the ItsDeductible exit, including its data shape; Valuation guidance for noncash donations is the core feature; Free tier covers light donors entirelyThe most guided interview in tax software; Imports from employers, banks, and brokerages broadly; Expert help tiers and in-person Intuit ecosystemCheaper than TurboTax at every comparable tier; Unlimited expert help included on paid DIY tiers; In-person offices if a return goes wrong
Watch out forTXF export pays only inside TurboTax Desktop; Young product next to the Intuit name it replaces; Valuations are guidance, not tax adviceFree Edition excludes most non-simple returns; State returns cost extra on every paid tier; Prices rise as the filing deadline approachesState returns cost $49 each on paid tiers; Prices climb as the deadline approaches; The interface is a step behind TurboTax in polish

Lowest entry price: H&R Block at $65 per month flat. Real free plan: Deductible Duck, TurboTax, H&R Block. Entry price is the floor, not the decision: check the plan line above for the tier that actually includes the feature you need.

All figures from vendor pricing pages, checked November 18, 2026. Some vendors price by contacts, tasks, or operations instead of seats; those notes are in the plan data and the linked pricing guides.

ItsDeducted, Charity Record, and the no-replacement option

ItsDeducted (at $29 per year in current reads) is the refugee-branded tracker: a straightforward donation log with valuations, named for the shutdown it answers, suitable for filers who want the familiar shape without evaluating the field. Charity Record is the light-duty free option, free up to $500 in donations in current reads, which covers the honest majority of casual donors entirely; households donating a few bags of clothing a year may need nothing paid at all. Then there is the option the tracker vendors will not advertise: if you file with TurboTax Online, its built-in fair market value tool (present by March 2026 per Intuit help text) values noncash donations inside the return itself, and a simple spreadsheet or notes log through the year plus that tool at filing time replaces ItsDeductible for many Online filers at $0. What it does not replace is the year-round discipline (photographs, receipts, per-item records at donation time), which was always the real product; any tracker, including a notebook, that captures the record when the bag leaves the house beats a valuation engine reconstructing it in April.

The TXF honesty test

Every tracker in this field advertises export, and the word conceals the bench's deciding fact. TXF (Tax Exchange Format) import is a TurboTax Desktop feature. TurboTax Online does not accept TXF files from any tracker, so a Desktop export is worthless to the growing majority who file online, however prominent the export button is on the tracker's homepage. Grade export claims against your actual filer: Desktop filers get real value from TXF (Deductible Duck, DeductAble); Online filers should grade trackers on their records and summaries (what you will retype or reference at filing), and H&R Block filers likewise, since the TXF path is a TurboTax Desktop path. A tracker whose export you cannot use is a diary, and a diary can still be the right purchase, priced as one.

Records discipline: the part no shutdown can take

The IRS rules did not change when the product died: noncash donations need records (what, when, to whom, fair market value, and how you determined it), donations of $250 or more need written acknowledgment from the charity, and single items or groups claimed above $500 trigger Form 8283, with appraisal rules above $5,000. A replacement tracker earns its price by making those records automatic at donation time: date, charity, item list, condition, valuation source, and a photograph. Whichever tool you choose, run the April test in January: donate one bag, log it, photograph it, and produce the summary you would hand your filer. The tool that makes that summary boring is the tool that replaced ItsDeductible; the valuation tables were always the smaller half of its value.

The verdict

TurboTax Desktop filers with real donation volume: Deductible Duck, or DeductAble when your ItsDeductible history survives as a CSV. Light donors: Charity Record free up to $500, or ItsDeducted at $29 per year for the familiar shape. TurboTax Online filers: seriously consider no replacement; log donations in any durable form through the year and use the built-in valuation tool at filing time, because the TXF exports the trackers sell cannot enter your return. The shutdown is a fact (October 21, 2025); the deduction survives it, and so does the discipline, in whichever tool you now keep it.

Interactive tool

The donation tracker move checklist

Check off each step as you finish it. Your progress stays on this page.

0 of 6 complete

0% done

Related guides

The shortlist does not end here. These related guides cover the sibling tools, matchups, and pricing questions closest to this one.

Frequently asked questions

When did ItsDeductible shut down?

Intuit shut ItsDeductible down on October 21, 2025. The charitable deduction itself did not change; what ended was the tracking and valuation workflow and its handoff into TurboTax.

What is the best ItsDeductible replacement?

Deductible Duck for most Desktop filers: free for the first $1,000 in donations, then $29.99 per year in current reads, with valuation guidance and TXF export. DeductAble if your ItsDeductible history survives as a CSV, since its import path is its headline feature. Light donors can stay free with Charity Record up to $500.

Does TurboTax accept imports from donation trackers?

TurboTax Desktop accepts TXF files. TurboTax Online accepts no TXF from any tracker, a fact tracker marketing underplays. Online filers should grade trackers on records and summaries, and note that TurboTax Online added a built-in fair market value tool by March 2026 per Intuit help text.

Can I still deduct donated clothing and household goods?

Yes, for itemizers, under the same rules as before the shutdown: fair market value in the condition donated, with records of what, when, and to whom. Donations of $250 or more need written acknowledgment from the charity, and claims above $500 in noncash goods trigger Form 8283.

I file with TurboTax Online. Do I need a tracker at all?

Maybe not a paid one. Log donations durably through the year (any tool, including a spreadsheet, with dates, charities, item lists, and photographs), then use TurboTax Online's built-in valuation tool at filing time. Paid trackers earn their price on discipline and records, not on an export Online cannot accept.

Photo credits: RDNE Stock project (Pexels). Photos are served from this site; follow the credit to the library page for the original.