Home / Software Alternatives

QuickBooks Alternatives With Payroll: Two Purchases Wearing One Query

A diverse group of professionals engaged in a meeting at a modern office, promoting teamwork and collaboration.

Photo: Tiger Lily / Pexels

One query, two purchases

Search results for this query mix two benches into one list and serve neither buyer. Purchase A is payroll as a product: your books are fine (maybe even QuickBooks books), and you want payroll that files taxes, handles multiple states, and prices sanely; the contenders are Gusto, OnPay, Patriot, and Square Payroll, against the incumbent QuickBooks Payroll add-on. Purchase B is books with payroll: you are replacing QuickBooks entirely and payroll must come along or integrate tightly; the contenders are accounting platforms plus their payroll stories. The benches have different winners and different math. Payroll math, specifically, is base fee plus per-person fee, which means every comparison must state a headcount or it states nothing. This article uses a five-person example throughout, and the calculator below lets you run your own.

Payroll productBasePer personFive-person monthly base math
Gusto Simple$49$6$49 + $30 = $79 before tier features
Gusto Plus$80$12$80 + $60 = $140
OnPay$49$6$49 + $30 = $79, single plan shape
Patriot Basic (DIY filing)$17$4$17 + $20 = $37, you file
Patriot Full Service$37$5$37 + $25 = $62, they file
QuickBooks PayrollPaid add-on to QuickBooks ($38 to $340 books tiers)VariesPrice on the vendor page with your tier

Purchase A: payroll only, graded

Gusto is the market's default answer: Simple at $49 base plus $6 per person, Plus at $80 plus $12, Premium at $180 plus $22, with the polish, benefits integrations, and employee self-service that made it the category's brand name. OnPay is the connoisseur's answer: one plan shape at $49 plus $6 per worker that includes much of what rivals tier-gate, with a reputation among accountants for accuracy and support; for a straightforward payroll, OnPay's single-plan honesty is the strongest value shape in this bench. Patriot is the price floor with a fork: Basic at $17 plus $4 per worker is DIY tax filing (you file; the software calculates), Full Service at $37 plus $5 hands filing to Patriot. That fork is the whole Patriot question: price your own filing time and error risk honestly, because the $25 gap between the two five-person figures above is the market price of not filing. Square Payroll belongs on the list for Square-native retail and food businesses whose time tracking and POS already live there. And the incumbent: QuickBooks Payroll is a paid add-on to the books tiers ($38 to $340), renamed QuickBooks Workforce in 2026 reads; its argument is integration with QuickBooks books, and it should be priced as books plus payroll together, never as payroll alone.

Interactive tool

Comparison Builder

Pick two or three products and see them side by side on the numbers that decide the purchase.

MeasureGustoOnPayPatriot Payroll
Starting paid price$6 per user/mo, billed annually$6 per user/mo, billed annually$4 per user/mo, billed annually
Free optionNo free plan; month-to-month pricing with no long-term contractNo free plan; one plan, no tiersNo free plan; free trial offered
PlansSimple: $6/user/mo annual · Plus: $12/user/mo annual · Premium: $22/user/mo annualPayroll: $6/user/mo annualBasic Payroll: $4/user/mo annual · Full Service Payroll: $5/user/mo annual
PlatformsWeb, iOS, AndroidWebWeb
Best forsmall teams hiring W-2 employees, owners who want payroll taxes handled, businesses adding benefitsmulti-state small employers, businesses that hate tier ladders, niche industries with mixed W-2 and 1099 staffbudget-first single-state employers, owners comfortable filing taxes on the Basic tier, very small crews
StrengthsAutomatic federal, state, and local tax filing on every plan; Unlimited payroll runs; Employee self-service and benefits access includedOne plan, so no tier upsell; Multi-state tax filing included at the single price; Onboarding and benefits administration includedLowest published entry price in small-business payroll; US-based support is the headline feature; Full Service tier still undercuts most rivals
Watch out forThe base fee means a one-person payroll still costs $55 a month on Simple; Multi-state payroll needs Plus; Add-ons (priority support, state registration) raise the billBase fee makes tiny payrolls cost the same to start as Gusto Simple; Smaller integration ecosystem than the biggest payroll brands; HR extras are add-onsBasic tier leaves tax filing on you; Time tracking and HR are add-ons; US payroll only

Lowest entry price: Patriot Payroll at $4 per user/mo billed annually. None of these has a real free plan, only trials. Entry price is the floor, not the decision: check the plan line above for the tier that actually includes the feature you need.

All figures from vendor pricing pages, checked November 18, 2026. Some vendors price by contacts, tasks, or operations instead of seats; those notes are in the plan data and the linked pricing guides.

The filing question decides more than the price

Payroll products differ most consequentially where demos show least: tax filing and error responsibility. Full-service products file federal, state, and local taxes and (read the terms) stand behind their filings to varying degrees. DIY tiers calculate and hand you the forms and the liability. Multi-state employees, local taxes in states that love them, garnishments, and new-hire reporting are where cheap payroll gets expensive. Before choosing, list your payroll's actual complications (states, localities, contractors mixed with employees, tips, clergy if you are a church, in which case read the churches bench for the SECA and housing allowance gate) and make each finalist answer for your list, not for a generic small business.

Purchase B: books with payroll attached

If you are replacing QuickBooks wholesale, payroll decides by integration. The realistic shapes: Xero or Zoho Books for the ledger with Gusto-class payroll integrated (Gusto's integration breadth is a genuine ecosystem asset); Wave for micro businesses with simple payroll needs; or staying inside one vendor where possible for support simplicity. Grade the junction, not the parts: does time flow from scheduling to payroll to books without re-entry, do payroll journals post to the right accounts automatically, and does year-end (W-2s, 1099s) close in one workflow. Our small business bench grades the books side; this page's rule is that in Purchase B, the payroll integration quality outranks small differences in either product alone.

Contractors, tips, and other edge wages

Some payrolls are not edge cases to their owners: contractor-heavy construction crews with certified payroll needs belong in the contractors bench conversation; tipped workforces need tip reporting and credit handling demonstrated, not promised; household employers need a different product class entirely. The generalist payrolls above handle standard small business payroll excellently and specialty payroll variously. Your specialty, if you have one, is the spec; bring it to the demo as a worked example with real numbers and watch what the software does, because payroll errors compound quietly and surface at the worst times (quarter ends, year ends, and employee exits).

Switching payroll without breaking people

Payroll migrations have a calendar: switch at a quarter boundary, ideally at year start, because year-to-date wages, taxes, and filings must transfer accurately or be reconstructed. Every finalist here offers migration help; take it, and verify the year-to-date figures employee by employee against the old system's last reports before the first live run. Run the first payroll in parallel if the stakes justify it. Employees forgive many software choices; they do not forgive a wrong first paycheck from the new system, and neither does a tax agency.

The verdict

Payroll only: OnPay for single-plan value, Gusto for ecosystem and polish, Patriot Full Service for price with filing included, Patriot Basic only if you genuinely enjoy filing. Books plus payroll: choose the ledger from the small business bench, then require Gusto-class integration or a demonstrated journal workflow. And price everything at your real headcount; in payroll, the per-person line is the price.

Interactive tool

SaaS Cost Calculator

The per-seat price is the small number. This is the real one: your team, a full year, both billing cycles.

Gusto Simple for 10 seats

$720.00 per year

Billed annually: $60.00 per month equivalent, paid once a year.

Billed monthly instead: $720.00 per year.

No annual discount on these figures, so monthly billing costs nothing extra and keeps you free to leave.

Bar: annual-billing cost as a share of monthly-billing cost for the same seats.

Plan prices from vendor pricing pages, checked November 18, 2026. Taxes, add-ons, and usage overages are not included, because vendors do not include them in the headline price either.

Related guides

Before you commit, it is worth a look at the nearest alternatives and comparisons, gathered below from the same section of the chart.

Frequently asked questions

What is the best alternative to QuickBooks Payroll?

For most small businesses, OnPay ($49 base plus $6 per worker, single plan) or Gusto (Simple $49 plus $6; Plus $80 plus $12; Premium $180 plus $22). OnPay wins on single-plan simplicity and accountant reputation; Gusto wins on ecosystem, benefits, and integrations. Patriot Full Service ($37 plus $5) is the price leader with filing included. The right answer depends on your states, complications, and headcount, which the calculator on this page prices.

How much does Gusto cost for a small team?

At the Simple tier, $49 a month base plus $6 per person: a five-person team is $79 a month before any add-ons. Plus is $80 plus $12 per person ($140 for five), and Premium is $180 plus $22. Always compute at your real headcount; payroll pricing headlines quote the base and bill the people.

Is Patriot Payroll really cheaper, and what is the catch?

Patriot's prices are lower (Basic $17 base plus $4 per worker; Full Service $37 plus $5), and the catch is the fork: Basic is do-it-yourself tax filing, where Patriot calculates and you file and carry the responsibility. Full Service removes the catch for $20 more in base fee at our example sizes. Neither is a trick; they are two products sharing a brand, and buyers should choose between them consciously.

Can I keep QuickBooks for books and use another payroll?

Yes; that is Purchase A in this article, and it is common. Gusto, OnPay, and Patriot all serve businesses whose books live elsewhere, and Gusto in particular is built around integrations. You keep your books workflow, replace only the payroll layer, and the integration posts your payroll journals back to the ledger.

When should I switch payroll providers?

At a quarter boundary, and ideally at the start of a tax year, so year-to-date wage and tax figures transfer cleanly. Avoid mid-quarter switches unless your current provider is actively failing; the reconstruction work and error risk outweigh a month or two of savings in almost every real case.

Photo credits: Tiger Lily (Pexels). Photos are served from this site; follow the credit to the library page for the original.