Two incumbents, one complaint
Mailchimp and Constant Contact are different products with different histories, but they bill the same way: by contacts. Mailchimp's Standard plan starts at $20 per month and scales with the size of your list, with paid tiers metered by contacts and a monthly send ceiling on top. Constant Contact prices the same way at the 500-contact band: Lite at $10.20 per month billed annually ($12 monthly), Standard at $29.75 ($35 monthly), and Premium at $68 ($80 monthly). In both systems the meter runs on the list itself. A contact you collected two years ago and have not emailed since costs exactly as much as the subscriber who opened yesterday's campaign.
That is why this query exists as a pair. The searcher has usually run one of the two, priced the other as the obvious escape, and discovered the second incumbent charges for the same thing. The comparison pages that rank first for this query mostly grade the two platforms against each other, editor against editor, which answers a question the searcher has already moved past. The useful question is not Mailchimp or Constant Contact. It is: what billing models exist that are not this one, and which of them fits the way you actually send?
Three structural exits exist. You can pay per send instead of per contact (Brevo). You can stay with subscriber pricing but move to a platform whose bands and free tier are far more forgiving (MailerLite). Or you can leave hosted pricing entirely and self-host (listmonk), trading a bill for an operational responsibility. Each exit is graded below on what it costs at real list shapes, because the right answer depends on two numbers most comparison pages never ask for: how many contacts you store, and how often you actually email them.
| Billing model | Example | You pay for | You stop paying for |
|---|---|---|---|
| Per contact (the incumbents) | Mailchimp, Constant Contact | Every stored contact, every month | Nothing; the meter is the list |
| Per send | Brevo | Emails actually sent | Storing a large list |
| Subscriber bands, gentle slope | MailerLite | Active subscribers in bands | Punishing jumps at band edges |
| Self-hosted | listmonk | Your server and sending provider | The platform bill entirely |
Exit one: pay per send with Brevo
Brevo inverts the incumbent model. Contacts are free to store (up to 100,000 on the free plan), and the meter runs on sends: the free plan allows 300 emails per day, roughly 9,000 a month, and paid plans start at $9 per month for 5,000 emails a month on Starter and $18 on Standard, scaling with volume rather than list size. For the classic victim of per-contact pricing, a business with 20,000 stored contacts that mails twice a month, this is the difference between paying rent on the whole list and paying for the 40,000 sends actually made.
The honest catches: the free plan carries Brevo branding and a daily send cap that makes a single big blast impossible without a paid tier, and volume pricing has its own cliffs at campaign peaks, when a launch month can cost several times a quiet month. Brevo also bundles SMS, WhatsApp, and chat in the same account, which is either a bonus or a distraction depending on whether you will use them. Deliverability tooling and the automation builder are a step behind Mailchimp's polish. But on the axis this query is actually about, the billing model, Brevo is the cleanest exit that still feels like a normal hosted platform.
Exit two: subscriber bands without the punishment, MailerLite
MailerLite still prices by subscribers, so it is not a model change; it is the same model run by a vendor with gentler numbers. The free plan covers 250 subscribers and 2,500 emails a month (reduced in June 2026, a change worth knowing because older roundups quote the old, larger free tier). Paid plans at the 500-subscriber band are Comfort at $10.80 per month billed annually ($12 monthly) and Power at $22.50 ($25 monthly), with unlimited sends and automation included from the first paid tier. Against Constant Contact Standard at $29.75 for the same 500 contacts, or a Mailchimp bill that climbs with every import, the arithmetic is simply kinder, and the editor and landing page builder are genuinely pleasant rather than a compromise you endure for the price.
The catches are the mirror image of Brevo's: because the meter is still the list, a fast-growing list still produces a growing bill, just a slower one, and MailerLite's account approval process can delay a brand-new sender's first campaign. If your problem is specifically that you store far more contacts than you mail, MailerLite softens the problem rather than solving it. If your problem is that the incumbents' per-contact prices at your current size are simply high for what you use, it solves it completely.
Exit three: the self-hosted endgame, listmonk
listmonk removes the platform bill altogether. It is a self-hosted newsletter and mailing list manager under the AGPL-3.0 license: one binary and a database, running on a server you control, with sending handed to Amazon SES or an SMTP relay whose per-send costs are a fraction of any hosted platform at volume. For a sender with 100,000 contacts and the technical capacity to run it, the monthly platform cost is zero and the sending cost is the only meter left.
This exit is real but it is not free of cost; the cost changes shape. Deliverability becomes your job: SPF, DKIM, bounce handling, and sender reputation are yours to operate. There is no drag-and-drop builder on the marketing-platform level, and the AGPL-3.0 terms matter if you modify the software and offer it as a service. The honest framing is that listmonk is the right answer for teams that already run infrastructure and the wrong answer for a two-person business that wants to send a newsletter on Friday. Both incumbents' refugees land here eventually if their lists keep growing; the only question is whether you arrive with the operational skills the tool assumes.
When staying is the right answer
Loyalty is not a strategy, but neither is migration for its own sake. Stay with Mailchimp or Constant Contact if your list is small and stable (the per-contact meter barely moves below a few thousand contacts), if your team depends on a specific integration or template workflow that the exits genuinely lack, or if your sending is so infrequent that even the incumbents' bill is smaller than the cost of re-platforming, re-permissioning, and warming a new sending domain. The per-contact model punishes growth and storage; it does not punish small, steady senders very much. Price your own shape in the calculator below before you conclude you are one of the punished.
The other honest case: if you are leaving only one of the two incumbents, the dedicated guides do that job better than this one. The Mailchimp alternatives flagship grades the Mailchimp exit field on its own, the Constant Contact ranking does the same for Constant Contact, and the free Constant Contact alternatives covers the zero-budget version of that exit. This article exists for the reader who has priced both incumbents and rejected the shared model.
