Photoshop Alternatives, Open Source: The License Bench (GPL, and One Impostor)
By the SoftSea editorial team
Photo: Borta / Pexels
Why a license bench exists
Most alternatives lists treat "free" as one word with one meaning. It has two: free of charge, and free as in freedom, and the readers of this query mean the second one. They want source code they can inspect, a license that cannot be revoked by a pricing page, and software that will still open their files in twenty years. That is a coherent, respectable shopping criterion, and it deserves a bench that audits licenses instead of vibes. Every tool below carries its actual license, read from the project's own materials for our dataset. Two popular names are graded as impostors: excellent freeware that is not open source at all, included because every competing listicle will recommend them to you under this query, wrongly.
Tool
License
Price
Role
GIMP
GPL
$0
The raster editor
Krita
GPL
$0
Painting and editing
darktable
GPL
$0
RAW development
RawTherapee
GPL
$0
RAW development, precision engine
digiKam
GPL
$0
Photo library management
Pinta
MIT-style (open source)
$0
Simple editing, Paint.NET-shaped
Photopea
Proprietary freeware
Free with ads
NOT open source
Paint.NET
Proprietary freeware
$0 (Windows)
NOT open source
The genuine bench: GIMP and Krita
GIMP and Krita are the core of the open source answer, both GPL, both $0, both cross-platform, both older than some of their users. GIMP is the Photoshop-shaped one: layers, masks, selections, and a feature depth built over decades. Krita is the painter's tool that grew into an editor, with the better brush engine and a large working-artist community. Between them they cover raster editing and illustration completely for most users. Their shared caveats are workflow caveats, not license ones: PSD round-tripping is good on ordinary files and imperfect on exotic ones, and CMYK prepress remains the weak room. GIMP 3.x and Krita 5.x are the current generations; install current builds, because old screenshots fuel most of the internet's opinions about both. The Linux bench grades them on their home platform, where this whole stack is native.
Interactive tool
Comparison Builder
Pick two or three products and see them side by side on the numbers that decide the purchase.
Measure
GIMP
Krita
darktable
Starting paid price
Free
Free
Free
Free option
Free plan: the whole program, free and open source (GPL), no account
Free plan: the whole program, free and open source from krita.org
Free plan: the whole program, free and open source, no account
Plans
Free: free
Free: free
Free: free
Platforms
Windows, macOS, Linux
Windows, macOS, Linux, Android
Windows, macOS, Linux
Best for
hobbyists and students, Linux users, anyone whose Photoshop use is layer basics
illustrators and painters, concept artists, Photoshop users whose work is mostly painting
RAW shooters leaving Lightroom, Linux photographers, high-volume hobbyists
Strengths
Full layer, mask, and channel editing at $0; Opens and exports PSD files; Huge plugin and script ecosystem
Best brush engine among free editors; PSD support good enough for painting round trips; Animation and comic tools built in
Closest free match to the full Lightroom shape: catalog plus develop; Non-destructive RAW pipeline with deep color tooling; Tethering, mapping, and print modules included
Watch out for
No native CMYK workflow for print shops; Adjustment layers are not equivalent to Photoshop smart workflows; Interface and defaults feel dated next to paid rivals
Photo retouching is a side door, not the main entrance; Text and vector tools are basic; Not a RAW or catalog tool at all
Steep learning curve; the module order matters; Cannot read Lightroom catalogs or apply Adobe profiles identically; Smaller tutorial and preset ecosystem
Lowest entry price: GIMP at Free per month flat. Real free plan: GIMP, Krita, darktable. Entry price is the floor, not the decision: check the plan line above for the tier that actually includes the feature you need.
All figures from vendor pricing pages, checked November 18, 2026. Some vendors price by contacts, tasks, or operations instead of seats; those notes are in the plan data and the linked pricing guides.
The photography wing: darktable, RawTherapee, digiKam
Open source photography is a full pipeline, not an editor with helpers. darktable covers RAW development in the Lightroom shape; RawTherapee covers it as a precision instrument with a different philosophy; digiKam manages libraries at a scale that embarrasses some commercial tools. All GPL, all $0. A photographer can run an entire professional workflow (ingest, manage, develop, edit in GIMP or Krita, export) without a single proprietary component, and many do. That completeness is unique to the open source bench: no commercial alternative field can say it, because each of their pipelines ends at a paywall or an account.
Pinta: the small honest option
Pinta earns a row for a specific user: the one whose Photoshop use was always overkill, cropping, annotating, light retouching, who wants a simple open source editor without GIMP's depth or interface commitments. It is open source, $0, and deliberately modest. Benches that grade Pinta against Photoshop are grading a bicycle against a truck; graded against its actual job, it passes cleanly, and its existence is a reminder that the best alternative is sometimes a smaller tool, honestly licensed.
The impostors, graded fairly
Photopea is a superb browser editor and the winner of our free online bench; it is also proprietary freeware, closed source, ad-supported. Paint.NET is a beloved Windows editor, free of charge, and proprietary. Neither belongs in an open source recommendation, and both appear in most of them, because listicles sort by price and stop reading. If your criterion is price, both are fine tools and this bench has no quarrel with them. If your criterion is the license (auditability, permanence, freedom to modify and redistribute), they fail it completely, and a bench that hides that has failed you. Affinity, for completeness, is also proprietary; its free-for-individuals pricing makes it the commercial answer, not an open source one.
What the GPL actually buys you here
Three concrete things. Permanence: GIMP versions from decades ago still run and still open their files; no pricing page can sunset your editor. Auditability: the code is public, which matters for security-sensitive and institutional users, and is why these tools pass IT reviews that freeware fails. And exit immunity: your skills and files are never hostage to a renewal. What the GPL does not buy: support contracts, guaranteed PSD fidelity, or an interface designed by a large product team. Price those honestly, and for most readers of this query the trade is the point of the query.
Maintenance and trust checks
Open source quality varies, so run the standing checks before adopting any project professionally: recent releases, an active repository, a public security policy, and a real community. GIMP, Krita, darktable, RawTherapee, and digiKam pass all four easily; that is part of why they are the bench. Install from official sources (project sites, your distribution, Flatpak) rather than download portals, which bundle junk with famous free software as a business model.
The verdict
For license-first shoppers: GIMP plus darktable (or Krita for painters) is the complete, permanent, $0 answer, with digiKam for libraries and Pinta for light work. Photopea and Paint.NET are good freeware and are not open source, whatever the listicles say. Your criterion was the license; this bench graded the license.
Interactive tool
The open source license and pipeline checklist
Check off each step as you finish it. Your progress stays on this page.
0 of 5 complete
0% done
Related guides
The shortlist does not end here. These related guides cover the sibling tools, matchups, and pricing questions closest to this one.
What is the best open source Photoshop alternative?
GIMP: GPL-licensed, $0, cross-platform, and the deepest raster editor in open source. Krita is the better painter. Together with darktable for RAW work, they form a complete open source photography and editing pipeline with no proprietary component anywhere in it.
Is Photopea open source?
No. Photopea is proprietary freeware: free of charge with ads, closed source, running in your browser. It is an excellent editor and the winner of the free online category, but recommending it as an open source alternative is a category error this bench exists to correct.
Is Paint.NET open source?
No. Paint.NET is proprietary freeware for Windows. It was briefly open source in its distant past, which is the fossil fueling the myth, but current versions are closed. The open source tool in its shape and spirit is Pinta.
Is Affinity open source?
No. Affinity is proprietary software that is currently free for individuals with a Canva account, with AI features behind Canva plans. That pricing makes it the strongest commercial answer in this series, but free of charge and open source are different claims, and only one of them survives a change of ownership or pricing.
Can open source editors open PSD files?
Yes, with the standing caveat: GIMP and Krita open ordinary layered PSDs well; exotic Photoshop features can flatten or shift. If your living depends on PSD round-trips with Adobe-standardized clients, test your real files first, and keep Photopea (proprietary, but fidelity-strong) as a browser fallback for stubborn files.
Photo credits: Borta (Pexels). Photos are served from this site; follow the credit to the library page for the original.